Welcome, Jim.
My first thought was to advise that you locate a replacement piece before you try removing what you have. Unless, of course, the shower is not in service and can sit idle while you secure such a replacement.
Depending upon how the piece was installed, I think your chances of intact removal are in the slim-to-none range. I think Gregg's last eye-dee is the best; just break it as necessary to remove it carefully enough so's not to damage any of the rest of the installation.
My opinion; worth price charged.